Court experts and party consultants

Appointments as court expert or technical consultant in matters of building, planning and landscape offences, environmental offences and workplace safety.

In proceedings concerning buildings, land, the environment and workplaces, the outcome often depends on a technical assessment: whether a work complies with its permits and planning instruments, when and how it was built, what links an activity to environmental damage, whether the preventive measures were adequate. The firm carries out these assessments in two distinct roles, which it keeps separate: as an expert or consultant appointed by the judicial authority, and as technical consultant to a party.

Appointments by the judicial authority

The firm's professionals, who are entered on the registers of court experts and technical consultants, carry out the appointments made by the judge and by the public prosecutor.

  • Expert opinion in criminal proceedingsAssessments requiring specific technical expertise, on questions put by the judge and with the parties' consultants taking part.
  • Technical consultancy for the public prosecutorAssessments during the preliminary investigation, including surveys and non-repeatable technical assessments.
  • Court-appointed technical consultancyIn civil proceedings and, where the judge orders it, in administrative proceedings.
  • Site visits and surveysExpert operations with notice to the parties, minutes, and plan, photographic and geo-referenced surveys.

Technical consultancy for a party

Technical assistance to a party to the proceedings: person under investigation, defendant, injured party, civil claimant, civilly liable party, corporate entity, applicant or public authority, from the investigation to trial.

  • Analysis of the case file and documentsReview of the case file, permits, maps and records, and identification of the assessments useful to the defence.
  • Assistance at expert operationsAttendance at site visits and technical assessments, with written observations and objections recorded in the minutes.
  • Party technical reportTechnical statements and reports, including in defence investigations (investigazioni difensive).
  • Support to legal counselTechnical support to counsel, including applications for the release of seized property and review of seizure orders.

Subject areas

Assessments usually touch several subject areas at once: a work built without a permit in a protected area, for example, raises building, planning and landscape issues together. We address them through a single reconstruction of the facts.

  • Building, planning and landscape offencesEstablishing the lawful state of a building and its discrepancies from the building authorisations: absence of permit, total or partial discrepancy, essential variations, construction tolerances. Dating of the works from records, orthophotos and historical maps, assessment of whether they can be regularised and of the certificate of compliance procedure, quantification of works, restoration and penalties, support in demolition orders and seizures. Compliance of works, subdivisions and changes of use with planning instruments, unauthorised land subdivision and changes of use. Works carried out in protected areas without landscape authorisation, landscape compatibility and the relationship with landscape plans. Disputes over municipal orders and refusals of retrospective approval.
  • Environmental offencesTechnical reconstruction of pollution incidents, waste management, discharges, emissions and contaminated sites. Critical review of sampling, analyses and inspection reports, estimate of the extent of the damage and of remediation and restoration costs, support in the procedure for extinguishing environmental misdemeanours and in the defence of the entity in proceedings on liability for offences.
  • Workplace safetyReconstruction of how accidents occurred and of the causes of occupational diseases. Review of the risk assessment document, of site safety plans, equipment, installations, training and protective equipment. Technical analysis of the preventive measures adopted and of those missing, in support of counsel's assessment, enforcement authority prescriptions, liability of the entity.

Independence

The firm does not accept engagements from a party in proceedings in which it has been appointed expert or consultant by the judicial authority, nor engagements from parties with opposing interests in the same proceedings.

The firm does not act as legal defence counsel: legal matters remain with the party's lawyer.

Contact us

Legal framework

  • Code of Criminal Procedure, Articles 220-233 (expert opinions and technical consultancy), Article 327-bis (defence investigations), Articles 359 and 360 (technical consultants of the public prosecutor and non-repeatable technical assessments)
  • Code of Civil Procedure, Articles 61-64 and 191-201 (court-appointed and party-appointed technical consultants); Legislative Decree no. 104 of 2 July 2010 (Code of Administrative Procedure), Articles 66 and 67 (independent verification and court-appointed technical consultancy)
  • Presidential Decree no. 380 of 6 June 2001, in particular Articles 9-bis (lawful state of buildings), 30 (unauthorised land subdivision), 31-37 (unauthorised works, demolition orders, certificate of compliance), 34-bis (construction tolerances), 36-bis (certificate of compliance for partial discrepancies and essential variations) and 44 (criminal penalties)
  • Regional Law of Sardinia no. 23 of 11 October 1985; Regional Law of Sardinia no. 45 of 22 December 1989; Regional Law of Sardinia no. 8 of 23 April 2015
  • Legislative Decree no. 42 of 22 January 2004, Articles 167 and 181 (works carried out without landscape authorisation, administrative and criminal penalties)
  • Legislative Decree no. 152 of 3 April 2006 (environmental code), in particular Part Three (discharges), Part Four (waste and remediation) and Part Six-bis, Articles 318-bis et seq. (extinguishing environmental misdemeanours); Criminal Code, Articles 452-bis et seq. (crimes against the environment, Law no. 68 of 22 May 2015)
  • Legislative Decree no. 81 of 9 April 2008 (workplace health and safety); Legislative Decree no. 758 of 19 December 1994 (enforcement authority prescriptions); Criminal Code, Articles 589 and 590 (manslaughter and negligent personal injury)
  • Legislative Decree no. 231 of 8 June 2001, Articles 25-septies and 25-undecies (liability of entities for workplace safety and environmental offences)

The references are up to date as at the date of publication. Building rules, national and regional, change frequently.

WhatsApp